Note: Properties with the Total Monthly Price badge include all required fees. Tap the badge for more details.
-

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Deals & Discount Filters
All Filters

Deals & Discounts

Price Range

–

Beds & Baths

Beds

Baths

Home Type

Pet Policy

Interior & Community Amenities

Speciality Housing

Keyword Search

  8. Building Photo - Shoregate
    STUDIO
    $2,959+
    1 BED
    $2,955+
    2 BEDS
    $3,969+
    3 BEDS
    $5,141+
    Total Monthly Price Total Monthly Price New
    Base Rent$2,840 - $11,150
    Required Monthly Fees$115
    Utilities & EssentialsVaries
    Total Monthly Price$2,955 - $11,265

    Shoregate

    143 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 954-2457
  34. Building Photo - 32 W Main St
    2 BEDS, 1 BATH
    $2,250
    Total Monthly Price Total Monthly Price New
    Base Rent$2,250
    Required Monthly FeesNone
    Total Monthly Price$2,250

    32 W Main St Unit 2

    32 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Apply
  35. Building Photo - 85 Cedar Dr
    3 BEDS, 1 BATH
    $3,500
    Total Monthly Price Total Monthly Price New
    Base Rent$3,500
    Required Monthly FeesNone
    Total Monthly Price$3,500

    85 Cedar Dr Unit BayShore

    85 Cedar Dr, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Apply
  36. 1 BED, 1 BATH
    $2,650
    Total Monthly Price Total Monthly Price New
    Base Rent$2,650
    Required Monthly FeesNone
    Total Monthly Price$2,650

    68 Park Ave Unit 2C

    68 Park Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  37. STUDIO, 1 BATH
    $1,900
    Total Monthly Price Total Monthly Price New
    Base Rent$1,900
    Required Monthly FeesNone
    Total Monthly Price$1,900

    89 Beatrice Ave

    89 Beatrice Ave, West Islip, NY 11795
Showing 42 of 88 results, Page 1 of 3

Bay Shore at a Glance

Average Rent

$2,580
(All bedrooms and property types)
Learn more about
Average Rent in Bay Shore
4

School Rating

out of 10 Rating
Learn more about
Schools in Bay Shore

Bay Shore, NY Apartments for Rent

Bay Shore sits along the Great South Bay on Long Island's South Shore, offering waterfront access and ferry service to Fire Island just minutes from the downtown area. This Suffolk County community features a walkable Main Street lined with local shops, restaurants, and cafes, while the bay provides opportunities for boating and waterside recreation. Those looking for apartments for rent in Bay Shore will find a range of housing options from historic buildings near the downtown core to garden-style apartment communities in quieter residential sections of the hamlet.

Renting in Bay Shore appeals to commuters and those seeking a coastal lifestyle within reach of New York City, as the Long Island Rail Road provides direct service to Penn Station in under 90 minutes. The downtown district offers dining and entertainment options, while nearby parks including Gardiner County Park provide beach access and outdoor space. Major roadways such as the Southern State Parkway and Sunrise Highway connect residents to employment centers across Long Island, and the area's proximity to both the bay and Fire Island makes it appealing for renters who value water access and recreational amenities.

Renting in Bay Shore

Average Rental Rates and Apartment Sizes

Top Budget-Friendly Neighborhoods in Bay Shore

(For 1 bedroom apartments)

Average Rent in Nearby Cities

(For 1 bedroom apartments)

Education

GreatSchools Rating
Bay Shore Senior High School

Public High School

Public
Grades 9-12
Students
GreatSchools Rating
Bay Shore Middle School

Public Middle School

Public
Grades 6-8
Students
GreatSchools Rating
West Middle School

Public Middle School

Public
Grades 6-8
Students
GreatSchools Rating
South Country School

Public Elementary School

Public
Grades K-5
Students
GreatSchools Rating
Hemlock Elementary School

Public Elementary School

Public
Grades K-5
Students
GreatSchools Rating
Gardiner Manor School

Public Elementary School

Public
Grades K-5
Students
GreatSchools Rating
Southwest Elementary School

Public Elementary School

Public
Grades K-5
Students

Data provided by GreatSchools.org 2025 © 2025. All rights reserved.

Apartments for Rent Near Bay Shore

Specialty Housing

Choose by Amenities

Bay Shore Apartments for Rent in Your Budget

Frequently asked questions about renting in Bay Shore, NY

What are the average rent costs in Bay Shore, NY?

The average rent in Bay Shore, NY is $2,580.

What are the average rent costs of a studio apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

The average rent for a studio apartment in Bay Shore, NY is $2,220.

What are the average rent costs of a one bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

The average rent for a 1 bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY is $2,580.

What are the average rent costs of a two bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

The average rent for a 2 bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY is $3,130.

What are the average rent costs of a three bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY?

The average rent for a 3 bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY is $4,234.

tooltips

I would like to...
0 out of 400 characters
By clicking above, you agree we may pass along your info so this property or the property’s affiliates can email, call, text, or autodial you to follow up and for any purpose. You also agree to... By clicking above, you agree we may pass along your info so this property or the property’s affiliates can email, call, text, or autodial you to follow up and for any purpose. You also agree to Apartmentfinder.com’s Privacy Statement and Terms of Service. Consent is not a condition for services. Message and data rates may apply. Read More Read Less

Submitting Request

Thank You

Your email has been sent.

Learn about our ratings.