3 BEDS, 1.5 BATHS
$3,500
Deals & Discount Filters
Apartments for Rent in Fire Island, NY
177 Rentals
-
-
3 BEDS, 2 BATHS$8,000368 Surf Rd
368 Surf Rd, Islip, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 2 BATHS$3,60053 Magnolia Dr
53 Magnolia Dr, Mastic Beach, NY 11951 -
6 BEDS, 5 BATHS$9,000
953B Dune Rd
953B Dune Rd, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978 -
5 BEDS, 2 BATHS$6,500
921 Evergreen Walk
921 Evergreen Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 3 BATHS$35,000
20 Dune Ln
20 Dune Ln, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978 -
5 BEDS, 3 BATHS$13,000
345 Dehnhoff Walk
345 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
3 BEDS, 1 BATH$7,500
647 Ocean Breeze Walk
647 Ocean Breeze Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 2 BATHS$7,150
342 Dehnhoff Walk
342 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
3 BEDS, 1 BATH$40,000
66 Bungalow Ln
66 Bungalow Ln, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 1.5 BATHS$6,000
291 Cottage Walk
291 Cottage Walk, Islip, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 2.5 BATHS$13,000
109 Bungalow Ln
109 Bungalow Ln, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
3 BEDS, 2 BATHS$6,000
139 Bungalow Ln
139 Bungalow Ln, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 2 BATHS$5,000
20 Ocean Rd
20 Ocean Rd, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
5 BEDS, 2.5 BATHS$12,500
294 Wilmot Rd
294 Wilmot Rd, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 1 BATH$14,400
329 Surf Rd
329 Surf Rd, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
1 BED, 1 BATH$25,000
49 Bay Ave
49 Bay Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
5 BEDS, 2 BATHS$12,000
39 Seneca Walk
39 Seneca Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
3 BEDS, 1.5 BATHS$35,000
9 Beachwold Ave
9 Beachwold Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 2 BATHS$6,000
102 Marine Walk
102 Marine Walk, Saltaire, NY 11706 -
3 BEDS, 2.5 BATHS$30,000
50 East End Walk
50 East End Walk, Bay Shore, NY 11706 -
3 BEDS, 2 BATHS$24,000
29 Superior Ave
29 Superior Ave, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 2 BATHS$6,500
485 Bayberry Walk
485 Bayberry Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
3 BEDS, 2.5 BATHS$10,000
50 Homesite Ave
50 Homesite Ave, Islip, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 1.5 BATHS$6,500
876 Evergreen Walk
876 Evergreen Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 3.5 BATHS$15,000
929 Dune Rd
929 Dune Rd, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978 -
STUDIO, 1 BATH$4,000
33 Sextant Walk
33 Sextant Walk, Islip, NY 11770 -
5 BEDS, 2.5 BATHS$5,000
6 Champlain Walk
6 Champlain Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770 -
5 BEDS, 2 BATHS$10,000
244 Cottage Walk
244 Cottage Walk, Islip, NY 11770 -
5 BEDS, 2 BATHS$13,500
38 Oneida St
38 Oneida St, Brookhaven, NY 11770 -
5 BEDS, 3 BATHS$17,500
240 Wilmot Rd
240 Wilmot Rd, Islip, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 2 BATHS$35,000
42 Evergreen
42 Evergreen, Islip, NY 11770 -
4 BEDS, 2 BATHS$10,000
5 E Bayview
5 E Bayview, Brookhaven, NY 11770 -
3 BEDS, 2 BATHS$36,000
7 Cove Ln
7 Cove Ln, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978 -
5 BEDS, 3 BATHS$10,000
16 Crescent
16 Crescent, Islip, NY 11770 -
3 BEDS, 2 BATHS$10,000
846 Dune Rd
846 Dune Rd, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978 -
3 BEDS, 2 BATHS$7,500
78 Hawser Dr
78 Hawser Dr, Babylon, NY 11702 -
4 BEDS, 3.5 BATHS$7,500
44 Island Walk
44 Island Walk, Bay Shore, NY 11706 -
8 BEDS, 4 BATHS$16,000
100 E Lighthouse Walk
100 E Lighthouse Walk, Islip, NY 11706 -
3 BEDS, 2 BATHS$8,000
39 Schooner Walk
39 Schooner Walk, Islip, NY 11770 -
2 BEDS, 1 BATH$32,000
30 Gale Walk
30 Gale Walk, Islip, NY 11770 -
3 BEDS, 2 BATHS$3,200
87 St George Dr
87 St George Dr, Shirley, NY 11967
Showing 42 of 177 results, Page 1 of 5
Fire Island at a Glance
Fire Island, NY Apartments for Rent
Fire Island, a narrow barrier island paralleling Long Island's South Shore, offers a distinctive car-free environment for those seeking apartments for rent. This 31-mile-long island features pristine beaches, the historic Fire Island Lighthouse, and the Otis Pike Fire Island High Dune Wilderness. The island's population fluctuates seasonally, with communities like Cherry Grove and Fire Island Pines each contributing to the area's diverse character.
Apartments for rent in Fire Island provide access to a lifestyle where residents travel by foot, bicycle, or water taxi. The island encompasses several communities, including the incorporated villages of Ocean Beach and Saltaire, along with smaller hamlets like Davis Park and Fair Harbor. While winters are peaceful, summer brings increased activity to local restaurants and shops. Regular ferry service from Bay Shore, Sayville, and Patchogue on Long Island connects residents to the mainland while preserving the island's natural setting.
Average Rent in Nearby Cities
(For 1 bedroom apartments)- Cities Average Rent
- Patchogue $2,630/mo
- Cherry Grove $25,000/mo
- Bayport $2,000/mo
- Sayville $2,364/mo
- East Patchogue $2,448/mo
- West Sayville $2,415/mo
- Bellport Village $2,997/mo
- Holbrook $2,689/mo
- Oakdale $3,364/mo
- Medford $2,552/mo
- Bohemia $2,439/mo
- Ocean Beach $3,200/mo
Getting Around Fire Island
Education
Data provided by GreatSchools.org 2025 © 2025. All rights reserved.
Apartments for Rent Near Fire Island
Specialty Housing
Choose by Amenities
tooltips
Submitting Request
Thank You
About Our Deals
Apartment Finder utilizes the industry's largest and most complete database of real-time rents and availabilities to help you find an amazing deal on your next rental.
Price Drop
Apartment communities change their rental rates often - sometimes multiple times a day. We track the changes and keep you up to date when a rental rate decreases.
Best Value
"Best value" units are located in buildings rated three stars or higher. We label apartment rentals that are priced significantly less than similar high-quality units nearby.
Rent Specials
Apartment communities regularly advertise deals for new residents. Whether it's a move-in special or a free tv, we locate the rentals that offer a little something extra when you sign your lease.
Note: Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice.