-

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Deals & Discount Filters
All Filters

Deals & Discounts

Price Range

–

Beds & Baths

Beds

Baths

Home Type

Pet Policy

Interior & Community Amenities

    • See More
    • See Less

Speciality Housing

Keyword Search

  8. 3 BEDS, 2 BATHS
    $24,000

    9 Country Club Dr

    9 Country Club Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  12. Building Photo - 5 Bay Ave
    3 BEDS, 3 BATHS
    $25,000

    5 Bay Ave

    5 Bay Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  14. 5 BEDS, 5.5 BATHS
    $40,000

    61 Peconic Ave

    61 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  16. 3 BEDS, 2 BATHS
    $5,000

    3 St Johns St

    3 St Johns St, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  18. 4 BEDS, 2 BATHS
    $14,000

    3 Lakeview Dr

    3 Lakeview Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964
  19. 4 BEDS, 4.5 BATHS
    $190,000

    18 North Dr

    18 North Dr, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Shelter Island at a Glance

Average Rent

N/A
(All bedrooms and property types)
0

School Rating

out of 10 Rating
Learn more about
Schools in Shelter Island
0

Some Transit

out of 100 TransitScore® Rating
Learn more about
Transportation in Shelter Island
32

Somewhat Bikeable

out of 100 BikeScore® Rating
Learn more about
Transportation in Shelter Island

Shelter Island, NY Apartments for Rent

Nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, Shelter Island is accessible by ferry from Greenport or North Haven. This 12-square-mile island features pristine beaches and the Mashomack Preserve, which covers nearly one-third of the island. The preserve offers hiking trails and wildlife viewing opportunities, while the island's coves and harbors provide water recreation options throughout the warmer months.

Shelter Island Heights showcases well-preserved Victorian architecture, reflecting the area's rich heritage. The island, home to approximately 2,400 year-round residents, maintains regular ferry service to mainland Long Island. Local amenities include the Shelter Island Country Club, multiple public beaches, and the historic Shelter Island Heights Historic District. The downtown area provides essential services, while the surrounding waters offer boating, fishing, and beach activities.

Average Rent in Nearby Cities

(For 1 bedroom apartments)
  • Cities Average Rent

Getting Around Shelter Island

Transportation

24

Car-Dependent

out of 100 WalkScore® Rating
You might be able to get out and walk when living in this area. Some errands can be accomplished on foot, but for others you need a car.
32

Somewhat Bikeable

out of 100 BikeScore® Rating
You might be able to find places to ride your bike in this area, but you'll most likely want your car for most errands.
0

Minimal Transit

out of 100 TransitScore® Rating
You'll likely want a car when living in this area since it has few transit options.
Scores provided by Walk Scoreⓘ

Education

Data provided by GreatSchools.org 2025 © 2025. All rights reserved.

tooltips

I would like to...
0 out of 400 characters
By clicking above, you agree we may pass along your info so this property or the property’s affiliates can email, call, text, or autodial you to follow up and for any purpose. You also agree to... By clicking above, you agree we may pass along your info so this property or the property’s affiliates can email, call, text, or autodial you to follow up and for any purpose. You also agree to Apartmentfinder.com’s Privacy Statement and Terms of Service. Consent is not a condition for services. Message and data rates may apply. Read More Read Less

Submitting Request

Thank You

Your email has been sent.

Learn about our ratings.